The union for health and care managers

Home  >  News & Campaigns  >  Features  >  Legal Eye: Bullying or Performance management? Where to draw the line
Thursday 01 September 2016

Bullying or performance management? Where to draw the line

By Jo Seery

Our legal advisers explain how to avoid allegations of bullying or harassment when managing poor performance.

Legal Eye_2016-09-01_Bullying_Interview

Carrying out appraisals is often a challenging process for managers, particularly when difficult conversations about poor performance are required. There has been a recent increase in MiP members reporting that they have been accused of bullying and harassment when tackling poor performance. Such accusations can have severe implications – including suspensions or unpleasant, protracted investigations, so it’s important that managers understand how the law deals with accusations of bullying.

‘Bullying’ is not defined in law but is described in the ACAS guidelines on bullying and harassment at work as “offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting behaviour, an abuse or misuse of power through means that undermine, humiliate, denigrate or injure the recipient”.

While most people will recognise extreme cases, when it’s less obvious there is a thin line, often open to interpretation, between what is and what’s not bullying.

A manager may feel they are being completely fair by pointing out poor performance and attempting to put in place measures to rectify the problem. Indeed, this is part and parcel of the job. However, this same process may make the employee feel they are being singled out for criticism, victimised and undermined for no reason.

There are a number of ways in which managers can address poor performance while doing their best to avoid allegations of bullying. Managers should always ensure that conversations about poor performance are dealt with privately and confidentially – they should never take place in front of other members of staff.

It’s also important to prepare evidence of poor performance before the discussion. This could be from previous appraisals, measures of performance against targets or examples where the employee has fallen short of expectations. Where targets or standards have been set, check that the employee has agreed these and, where they are not being met, that the employee is aware of concerns about their performance and has received support and guidance.

Lastly, all criticism should be constructive. While this may seem obvious, it is not always easy to do and a member of staff is far more likely to feel victimised if they feel that they are being criticised without any evidence or suggestions on how to improve their performance.

Managers should ensure that the reason for any criticism has nothing to do with the employee characteristics protected under the Equality Act 2010: age, disability, gender (including gender reassignment), race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation. While a manager may not be taking any of these into consideration when criticising poor performance, an employee may nevertheless believe that the reason for any criticism is because of a protected characteristic and claim that they have been subject to harassment.

Unlike bullying, harassment is defined in law as: “Unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic, which has the purpose or effect of violating an individual’s dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for that individual.” Even if the harassment is unproven, an allegation can still do serious damage to a manager’s reputation.

We recommend that workplaces should have a clear policy aimed at avoiding bullying and harassment, which staff can access easily. Training should also be provided on the policy, the procedure for reporting accusations and how any complaint should be taken forward.

If you are accused of bullying at work, your first port of call should be your union. Your MiP rep or national officer will be able to give you expert advice on your case and inform you on the next steps to take to protect your reputation against spurious allegations.

Jo Seery is an employment rights professional support lawyer at Thompsons Solicitors. Legal Eye does not offer legal advice on individual cases. MiP members in need of personal advice should immediately contact their MiP rep or national officer.

If you enjoyed this article, please sign up to receive our free monthly emails - and we’ll keep you up to date on news and events in health and care management

Group of women smiling at a meeting

Local MiP reps and link members are entitled to time off for their trade union duties. Our legal advisers explain your rights.

20 May 2020 | By Richard Arthur
Legal Eye

It’s illegal for your manager or employer to victimise you for being a member of MiP or carrying out MiP activities. Here we explain the legal protection available to you.

23 December 2019 | By Rachel Haliday
Legal Eye

Thousands of NHS staff could soon lose their automatic right to work in the UK. Here's what you need to know about getting ‘settled status’ for your EU workers.

19 June 2019 | By Rachel Halliday
Legal Eye

We explain the legal position behind so-called ‘gagging’ clauses which are now a common feature of settlement agreements in the NHS.

12 March 2019 | By Natalie Hunt
Legal Eye

We explain the legal duties on employers to protect the psychological wellbeing of staff and support people suffering from mental health conditions.

04 October 2018 | By David Robinson
Legal Eye
Fat cat eating a bowl of food

The Civil Liability Bill will deny injury compensation to thousands of workers and cost the NHS millions – just to feed the insurance industry fat cats.

27 July 2018 | By Doug Christie
Legal Eye

We explain what you need to know about about putting in a claim to an Employment Tribunal – and when to do it.

24 April 2018 | By Bernie Wentworth
Legal Eye

With more and more people leaving the NHS under settlement agreements, managers need to know what can and can't be said. Iain Birrell explains the rules about so-called 'protected conversations'.

15 December 2017 | By Iain Birrell
Legal Eye

Here's what you need to know about the legal position on using social media at work, focusing on human rights, contract law and data protection.

29 September 2017 | By Jo Seery
Legal Eye

Here's what you need to know about your legal responsibilities as a manager when handling race discrimination complaints from staff.

24 June 2017 | By Rakesh Patel
Legal Eye
Find us

Centenary House, 93-95 Borough High Street, London SE1 1NL

Copyright © 2018 MiP