MiP Logo for MiP the Union for Health and Care Managers

The union for health and care managers

Home  >  News & Campaigns  >  News Articles  >  MiP Summit 2020: The new normal in the NHS
Tuesday 03 November 2020

MiP Summit: “Disruptive transformation” of NHS could last for years

By Alison Moore

The panel discussing the 'new normal' (clockwise from top left): Habib Naqvi, Jon Restell, Rebecca Smith; Christine McAnea and David Cain.
The panel discussing the 'new normal' (clockwise from top left): Habib Naqvi, Jon Restell, Rebecca Smith; Christine McAnea and David Cain.

The COVID-19 pandemic has unleashed “phenomenal and disruptive transformation” in everyday life and changes in the NHS that could last for many years, MiP chief executive Jon Restell told delegates at the opening session of the union’s virtual Summit on 2 November.

Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, this year’s annual gathering of MiP members takes the form of 90-minute virtual meetings spread over the week. Monday’s first session featured a panel discussion on the “new normal” in the NHS and its implications for managers.

Chairing the discussion, Restell said the pandemic had “laid bare” the inequalities endured by BAME staff and patients, and “brutally exposed” the failings in social care. The NHS had “performed brilliantly in the most difficult circumstances when there was no road map to follow,” he said, but warned that managers – now facing the second wave alongside winter pressures and in many cases without being able to take a proper break - were now under working under extreme pressure under conditions of great uncertainty.

The widespread and rapid adoption of new digital technology and homeworking has posed difficult issues for managers, Restell said. He pointed to the results of a poll of delegates, taken during the discussion, which found that 20% per cent felt they did not have adequate IT equipment to do their job effectively.

Rethinking homeworking

Rebecca Smith, managing director of NHS Employers, agreed. “Not everyone is well set up for homeworking, with adequate space and equipment,” she said. “I feel some people really embrace home working and others find it more of a challenge. We need to think about different levels of support for people.”

People also felt fatigued from continuous virtual meetings and having to be “always available” – especially outside normal working hours and at weekends, Smith warned. Protecting people’s health and wellbeing was becoming ever more important, she said, as many people were likely to continue working from home for at least some of the time. She said employers needed to revisit their arrangements for homeworking to ensure people felt supported in the longer-term.

Short memories

Looking further ahead, UNISON assistant general secretary Christina McAnea raised concerns about NHS funding in the post-pandemic era. The government could “come after” the public sector, she warned, and this might include looking to reduce public sector pay and pensions. There were already moves towards redundancies in local authorities, she said, and she did not expect the NHS to be immune from these pressures after the pandemic. “People have short memories… There has been a recognition that we have to work together to get through this. It would be good to keep this going as we move forward,” she said.

She stressed the importance of implementing a proper workforce strategy across the NHS and especially social care, where many staff had been working under “enormous pressure” in very low-paid jobs. “You can’t do anything until you get the workforce right,” she said.

Learning lessons

Looking ahead to the likely inquiry into the handling of the pandemic, David Cain, chair of MiP’s National Committee, warned that managers could be made to carry the blame. This had already started to some extent, he said, with the debates about the shortages of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and lack of hospital capacity during the first wave. “We have to be pretty careful as a union that we protect managers against unnecessary criticism,” he said.

He called for the debate to focus on learning lessons rather than apportioning blame. “In the NHS, social care and local and central government, we will all need to work together to get through this dark winter ahead of us,” he said. “We will have to call on our professional and personal reserves like never before.”

Equality ‘went out the window’

Dr Habib Naqvi, director of the newly-founded NHS Race and Health Observatory, linked the under-representation of BAME people at the top levels of the NHS to the health inequalities exposed by the pandemic. “A change of culture is vital,” he said, pointing out that over half of new staff joining the NHS last year were from a BAME background.

“One of the big challenges for me was to see how quickly equality, diversity and inclusion went out of the window as soon as we started working away from the norm in an emergency situation,” he added. “The crucial element of the observatory is its independence. I think we now need to move away from the NHS setting its own exam paper and marking it on this critical agenda.”

Restell added that the omission of a crucial chapter on the impact of the virus on BAME people from Public Health England’s initial report on the crisis had been “electric”, and threatened to undermine the confidence of BAME communities in the health and social care system.

If you'd like to read more from MiP, sign up to receive our free monthly emails – we’ll keep you up to date on news and events in health and care management

Phot of office desk with a laptop and phone displaying MiP website

MiP are looking for an Organiser (fixed-term) to join our head office team.

29 January 2024 | By MiP

Help MiP and UNISON prepare for the 2024 pay round by taking part in our survey on NHS pay. It only takes a few minutes.

18 December 2023 | By MiP
trolley in busy hospital corridor

NHS managers have their say on professional regulation, suggesting it won't improve how the NHS handles concerns raised by staff.

08 December 2023 | By MiP
MiP virtual summit graphic 2021

Thank you for joining us for our online Member Summit 2023. All sessions are available for members to replay. Catch up on what you missed here.

13 November 2023 | By MiP
Jon Restell BBC Breakfast Interview

Watch MiP chief executive Jon Restell's interview on BBC Breakfast (28 August) discussing the events of Countess of Chester and calls for statutory regulation of NHS managers.

01 September 2023 | By MiP
Green vote logo

Elections to MiP's National Committee for 2024-25 are taking place for all nations and regions of the UK. Find out more about the committee's work and how to get yourself nominated.

28 July 2023 | By MiP
trolley in busy hospital corridor

Failure to incorporate pay and consider management functions in long term workforce plan a 'big risk', says MiP chief executive Jon Restell.

03 July 2023 | By MiP
trolley in busy hospital corridor

New research by think tank IPPR highlights the scale of undermanagement in the NHS and how it is preventing clinicians from treating patients

08 June 2023 | By MiP
Copyright © 2022 MiP