Managers’ revolving door damaging NHS, admits minister

Failing NHS organisations are often characterised by excessive turnover among managers, health minister Philip Dunne told Summit delegates at the evening Parliamentary reception – and he promised to spend his time in office strengthening leadership development.
Dunne, minister of state at the Department of Health since July 2016, said that every trust in special measures has had a “problem with leadership – and the leadership problem often comes from a revolving door” in senior posts.
When executives aren’t in post “for long enough to be respected by the clinicians and the management structures underneath them, things that they try to change don’t get implemented,” he warned.
Management “vitally important”
His goal is to “instil a greater sense of leadership development and talent spotting and talent management across the NHS,” Dunne said, particularly by encouraging more clinicians and people from ethnic minorities into leadership jobs. “The role of management is less talked about than most of the other roles within the NHS, but it’s vitally important,” he added.
Dunne was introduced by Labour MP and MiP member Karin Smyth, a former NHS manager in Bristol. She told delegates she joined the NHS to help make it “more responsive to local people and more democratically accountable.” But she eventually grew frustrated with the constant reorganisations, and left to continue her mission in Parliament.
“You do an incredibly difficult job,” she said. “I’m very proud to have had a career in NHS management.”
MiP has welcomed a 5% pay rise for very senior and executive senior managers in the NHS in England, after the UK government accepted the latest recommendations from the Senior Salaries Review Body (SSRB).
09 September 2024
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
The health secretary’s plans to cut 5,500 management jobs to fund community services if the Conservatives win the general election have been criticised as “not credible” by Labour and “paper thin” by MiP.
25 June 2024
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
NHS leaders must show how they are driving service improvement, delivering transformation, promoting equality and developing a just culture as part of new “competency framework” for directors introduced by NHS England this month.
04 April 2024
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
The latest NHS Staff Survey showed a modest improvement in staff morale, but found NHS workers were facing record levels of discrimination, and a significant proportion still plan to leave their jobs in the near future.
20 March 2024
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
MiP has called on Patricia Hewitt’s review of ICS powers to strike the right balance between local autonomy and central direction, warning that many NHS managers will be suspicious of the ideological motives behind the review.
19 December 2022
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
A majority of the public believe an above-inflation pay rise for NHS staff would be fair and workers would be justified in taking strike action if this year’s wage increase fails to match the rising cost of living, according to a new poll.
18 July 2022
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
NHS Confed survey finds racism deters 60% of ethnic minority leaders from recommending NHS management careers, with racist abuse and discrimination most likely to come from colleagues.
22 June 2022
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
NHS managers need to see “significant workforce interventions” – including an inflation-busting pay rise for NHS staff – if they are to manage the staffing crisis in the NHS and lead the recovery from the pandemic, MiP says.
10 February 2022
| By MiP
News
|
|||||
MiP Summit 2021: On day four, Matthew Taylor, Chris Creegan and Geoff Underwood discuss managing change under pressure, motivating people and how managers can be open, honest and even vulnerable in the face of the crisis.
16 November 2021
| By Alison Moore
News
|
|||||
MiP Summit 2021: On day three, MiP chief executive Jon Restell gave his update on pay and conditions across the UK, and UNISON’s Alan Fox briefed members on the changes to NHS pension schemes following the McCloud judgement.
12 November 2021
| By Craig Ryan
News
|
|||||
|
Related News
-
Managers paying a heavy price for 3.6% NHS pay rise, says MiP
Most NHS staff will get an annual pay rise of 3.6% after the government accepted the recommendation of the NHS Pay Review Body. But board level managers are set to get less and doctors more under pay awards announced today.
-
It’s your future: our guide to consultations in your workplace
As yet another round of reorganisation gets underway in the NHS in England, our new guide to workplace consultations will help you to help yourself, support your colleagues and protect the services you manage.
-
MiP responds to the abolition of NHS England
Government risk repeating same mistakes as Lansley by abolishing NHS England and cutting more staff from ICBs, says MiP.