MiP Logo for MiP the Union for Health and Care Managers

The union for health and care managers

Home  >  News & Campaigns  >  News Articles  >  MiP Summit 2020: Tackling race inequality in the NHS
Thursday 05 November 2020

MiP Summit: Racism doesn’t stop when you’re a manager

By Craig Ryan

Karen Bonner, Buckinghamshire Healthcare Trust
Karen Bonner (Buckinghamshire Healthcare Trust): “We have to listen and act. There’s enough evidence out there to guide us.”

Racism doesn’t disappear when you get to senior levels – it stays close and causes distress to everybody, every day,” MiP National Committee member Yvonne Richards told delegates at MiP’s virtual Members’ Summit on 3 November.

This year’s Summit takes the form of 90-minute virtual meetings spread over the week. Tuesday’s session featured a panel discussion on how employers and unions can work together to tackle racism in the NHS.

Chairing the debate, Richards summarised the feedback from MiP’s recently-formed focus group of BAME members and explained that the union’s casework showed that “black members are disproportionally represented in negative procedures like capability, disciplinary and discrimination.”

Accepting racism exists

Cheryl Samuels, deputy director of workforce transformation at NHS England/Improvement warned it was “naive” for managers to think racism wasn’t a problem in the NHS. “The people we employ are are a section of society and some of those ugly behaviours we see in society are mirrored in our organisations,” she said.

She explained that unfair recruitment practices and informal arrangements – such as “people being tapped on the shoulder, nepotism and people belonging to clubs” – served to “marginalise minority groups even further.” Employers and unions needed to eliminate bias from arrangements for secondments and ‘acting up’ assignments, as well as access to “sexy training”, she said.

Helga Pile, UNISON’s deputy head of health, said it was “distressing” to hear that some union members feared “they would be treated as the problem” if they raised an issue about racism. “As trade unions, we’ve got to say these things are not acceptable and find ways to turn it round,” she added.

Listen and act

Karen Bonner, chief nurse at Buckinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust, said: “We have to listen and act. There’s enough evidence out there to guide us.” She urged managers to “really listen to staff and not invalidate what they’re telling you – even if it’s uncomfortable. As a manager you have to ask, ‘What do I have to change to improve the experience that staff are having?’”

Samuels added: “Leaders have an absolute responsibility to sit up and listen, but also be conscious that discomfort is often where the greatest growth and learning happens.”

It was also important for NHS organisations “to recruit against our values as well as technical capabilities”, she said, pointing out that the vast majority of dismissals and disciplinary cases centred on conduct rather than capability.

Responsibility for tackling racism and discrimination “is too often put back on the people who are actually experiencing it”, Bonner said. “If you are managing people from different backgrounds, you have to recognise and understand that they come with difference. It won’t always be easy for managers who are not people of colour, and you won’t always get it right, but it’s part of your responsibility.”

“Black people are exhausted,” added Yvonne Richards. “We’re tired and we’re now expected to teach people about something that we’ve been screaming about for at least the 26 years that I’ve been in the NHS.”

Helga Pile said it was important for leaders and union reps to show “curiosity” about other people’s experiences. “We’re looking for people to be less fearful of getting it wrong and more interested in asking questions because they want to understand,” she explained.

Cheryl Samuels, NHS England
Cheryl Samuels (NHS England): it’s “naive” to think racism isn’t a problem in the NHS.

Cheryl Samuels added: “Nobody needs to ask the question ‘why?’ anymore because there’s Google. People need to do their race homework.” She said NHS England was developing an “allyship programme” for white staff who wanted to support BAME colleagues. “We’ve got more white people than ever who really want to step up to the plate and do something about it. They recognise the injustice, they feel like they want to do something, but they need a bit of a framework,” she explained.

Racism is more sophisticated

Responding to questions about unconscious bias training, Bonner said research showed that such programmes don’t work on their own. Samuels agreed, saying that, while many organisations “had good intentions”, others had “subjected managers to these programmes just to be seen to be doing the right things”.

She said that union reps needed to recognise the seemingly-small “micro-aggressions” that often make up a pattern of discrimination. “People don’t really come out and say the things they used to say to my grandmother, who was a psychiatric nurse at Guy’s. It’s a lot more subtle and sophisticated now,” she explained. “When people come to them with issues, union reps need to be a voice for them… and the employer should be looking at that as an opportunity to change.”

Bringing the discussion to a close, Yvonne Richards described racism as “a challenge” to the NHS Constitution, which promises equal and fair treatment for everyone. “If we can’t get this right for the people we’re working with, how can we get it right for the people and communities we’re serving? We have to challenge ourselves honestly to do better,” she said.

If you'd like to read more from MiP, sign up to receive our free monthly emails – we’ll keep you up to date on news and events in health and care management

English currency in notes and coins

A majority of the public believe an above-inflation pay rise for NHS staff would be fair and workers would be justified in taking strike action if this year’s wage increase fails to match the rising cost of living, according to a new poll.

18 July 2022 | By MiP
Navina Evans, chief workforce officer, official portrait

MiP welcomes the merger of NHS England’s People Directorate with Health Education England but warns of “significant work ahead” to tackle record vacancies and high levels of staff burnout.

04 July 2022 | By MiP
audience listening at union meeting

Strong partnership working between unions, employers and government are essential to tackle the workforce issues facing the NHS. Jon Restell reports from the recent meeting of the national Social Partnership Forum.

28 June 2022 | By Jon Restell

NHS Confed survey finds racism deters 60% of ethnic minority leaders from recommending NHS management careers, with racist abuse and discrimination most likely to come from colleagues.

22 June 2022 | By MiP
Helen Carr on the MiP Stand at Confed Expo 2022 in Liverpool

MiP are excited to have a stand at NHS Confed Expo 2022 at the ACC Liverpool. We’ll be here on Wednesday 15 and Thursday 16 June.

15 June 2022 | By MiP
Large mosaic of red tiles with word NEWS

MiP welcomes Sir Gordon Messenger's independent review of health and social care leadership and calls for honesty and investment in implementing its recommendations.

08 June 2022 | By MiP
Press Release
TUC demo graphic

MiP will be joining our fellow trade unions by taking part in the TUC’s "We Demand Better" march and rally on Saturday 18 June in London. Find out more here.

07 June 2022 | By MiP
Green vote logo

We have three vacancies for MiP members to represent the union on the FDA's Executive Committee. Find out more and download a nomination form here.

26 May 2022 | By MiP
Copyright © 2021 MiP